The voices against Aryna Sabalenka are growing louder, with some of tennis’ most prominent voices weighing in. First, it was Brad Gilbert, Coco Gauff’s former coach, calling for a heavy fine over her meltdown at the WTA Finals. Now Serena Williams’ coach, Rennae Stubbs, has gone further, labeling the former world No. 1’s conduct “disgusting,” while measuring it against one of the ugliest episodes of Serena Williams’ career.
Watch What’s Trending Now!
“The bottom line is absolutely she should be fined,” Stubbs stated on her podcast. “Suspension, I don’t know, that’s not for me to make that decision. I certainly think it would be, I think in some ways if she was suspended, it might be a blessing in disguise for her,” she said on her podcast.
The incident in question took place during Sabalenka’s match against Elina Svitolina at the WTA Finals in Indian Wells. As the match slipped from her grasp (with Svitolina eventually winning 6-3, 3-6, 6-1), Sabalenka was captured on camera visibly frustrated and allegedly swearing in Russian during the deciding set. A clip of the incident spread quickly on social media, with some viewers interpreting her remarks as an anti-Ukrainian slur, although the exact wording could not be independently verified.
Sabalenka clarified on Instagram the next morning that the words were not directed at Svitolina. She described “a small group of spectators who were aggressively cheering my mistakes” and admitted “I should have handled my frustration differently,” while praising Svitolina’s performance and wishing her well. She did not say what the words were. That statement, though, rather than cooling down the matter, amplified the argument over what should happen next.
Svitolina, who has refused to shake hands with Russian and Belarusian players since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, did not shake Sabalenka’s hand at the net. Speaking to reporters on Saturday, she said she had seen the clip. “I hope our matches can be respected,” she said, adding that some of their earlier meetings had also come with unpleasant comments linked to the war. She also noted that Ukrainian supporters naturally want her to win.
The calls for action began almost immediately. On Saturday, journalist Jon Wertheim wrote on X that the WTA “MUST” fine her now that she had “effectively confirmed those vile, indefensible remarks.” He pointed out that the tour’s code “even alludes to obscene/derogatory remarks made to fans, not just officials and opponents,” and said the money should go to a Ukrainian charity.
Belarusian politician Pavel Latushka went further, saying she “should be banned from all WTA-sanctioned tournaments,” which he called “the only proportionate response.” Gilbert’s comments came days later. “You can’t be yelling swear words like that at a fan,” he said, calling the conduct “really poor.” He added: “I haven’t heard anything since then but I feel like she deserves a heavy fine.”
Stubbs also opened by noting that Sabalenka had not won a tournament since Miami and was now caught in “this controversy of her ripping the Ukrainian spectators in the crowd.” She said a Russian-speaking friend translated the remark for her, and her reaction was: “Whoa.” Her co-host, Caitlin Thompson, said most Russian and Belarusian speakers she had read believed the remark was “much more directed at Elina Svitolina,” and “much more derogatory” than general fan chatter. Stubbs agreed.
“There are cameras everywhere. There are microphones everywhere,” she said. “When you are playing a live tennis match in front of thousands of people and millions of people watching at home, you cannot say those things and get away with it in a way that it’s just a slap on the hand”.
“I don’t care if you’re number one in the world or number 100 in the world, that is disgusting behavior, and you know it’s bad when you have to make an apology. That was very bad.” But Stubbs criticism wasn’t limited to the outburst.
The 28-year-old four-time major champion started 2026 by winning Brisbane and reaching the Australian Open final, where she lost to Elena Rybakina, then took Indian Wells and Miami in March. She has not won a title since. She lost the US Open final to Rybakina as well. This season, after 107 weeks at world No. 1, she also fell to No. 2 by October and is now ranked third.
After Beijing, Stubbs had said Sabalenka’s “confidence level is so low” and that she has “no game plan B,” contrasting her with Coco Gauff, who she said will find a way and “play ugly.” When Sabalenka gets angry, Stubbs said, she “just looks at her player’s box, and says fix this for me.” Her latest verdict was just as blunt with similar words.
Sabalenka “has game plan A. She has zero feel,” Stubbs said. She credited Max Mirnyi, who has left the team, with improving Sabalenka’s net play, said the player needs to “start looking inward,” and suggested “breaking down the entire coaching team” to find “a new voice.”
Stubbs also pointed to the Australian Open and US Open final defeats and the loss to Baptiste in Madrid as painful blows that “really hurt her,” calling it “a real sliding doors moment.” Those were “matches she probably should have won,” she said, and “with her game style, it’s very hard to reel it back in.”
Serena Williams’ name comes up
Stubbs reached back to the most scrutinized moments of the career she knew up close.
“When you think about Serena saying the things that she said about, ‘I’m going to shove this ball down your throat’, and the abuse that she took and the fine that she had to sustain after that, I feel like that’s nothing compared to what was said on the court at Indian Wells in a lot of ways,” she said. If Williams was made to pay so heavily, Sabalenka should not be allowed to walk away with a token penalty, was Stubbs’ opinion.
What Williams took on was a heavy punishment. She was fined on the spot $10,500 after a tirade at a line judge during the US Open semi-final against Kim Clijsters in 2009, which was later raised to a record $82,500 for a major offense by the Grand Slam Committee. The tirade followed a foot-fault call, and because Williams was already facing match point, the point penalty for her conduct ended the match. She was also handed a two-year Grand Slam probation, which would have resulted in an automatic suspension from the US Open if she committed a serious violation again. Williams initially defended her passion in her press conferences before issuing a formal apology two days later, and the saga trailed her for years.
That said, under the WTA’s 2026 rules, players are prohibited from using audible obscenities anywhere within a tournament site. The rule defines an audible obscenity as profane language spoken clearly and loudly enough to be heard. Each violation can attract a fine of up to $5,000, and if it occurs during a match, the player can also face a penalty under the Point Penalty Schedule. In particularly flagrant or egregious cases, a single violation can additionally be classified as the major offence of aggravated behaviour, potentially resulting in further disciplinary action.
Whether the WTA shares Stubbs’ conviction is now the question hanging over the aftermath in Indian Wells.

