David O. Russell thought he was making a tribute to one of the greatest NFL coaches ever, a man he called the Picasso of football. “There’s plenty of documentaries, but this is our love letter.” And if that wasn’t enough, he had Nicolas Cage in the title role. What could go wrong?

Watch What’s Trending Now!

According to one authority on the coach, everything. Rich Podolsky wrote Madden & Summerall: How They Revolutionized NFL Broadcasting, a 248-page book built on interviews with Madden’s family, friends and many former colleagues.

ADVERTISEMENT

Just one day after the film’s release, Podolsky published a review on Awful Announcing, and calling it disappointing would be an understatement.

Guess the Team

NameDrop500 / 500 pts
Your answer

Guess whenever you want — the fewer clues you open, the more points you keep.

500points if you solve it now
Guesses ·No timer

“As the author of Madden & Summerall, I was anxious to see the new Amazon film Madden in the worst way. Unfortunately, that’s exactly what I got — a film that was bad in every way.”

ADVERTISEMENT

“What director David O. Russell delivered to Amazon was a bad cartoon version of part of John Madden’s life, minus the joy of a cartoon.”

For Podolsky, it was a rare miss for Amazon. In his column, he noted that the studio has had success with sports films before, calling Air (2023), its film about Nike, “terrific.” Madden, he said, fell well short.

ADVERTISEMENT

“It’s a shame the actors had to look so ridiculous,” Podolsky wrote, referring to Nicolas Cage and Christian Bale.

He also took issue with a scene in which Pat Summerall (Joel Murray) criticizes Madden to ABC’s Howard Cosell in the CBS booth ahead of their first game together. Podolsky pointed out that Cosell would never have walked into a competitor’s booth. Citing comments from CBS executive producer Terry O’Neil, he also wrote that Summerall had told the Dallas Morning News he missed his old partner, Tom Brookshier.

ADVERTISEMENT

In another scene, Raiders owner Al Davis tells Madden, “In a few years they might not want you,” after telling him about an audition with CBS. According to Podolsky, that line actually came from IMG agent Barry Frank. He recommended that viewers watch Fox’s 90-minute special All Madden, which aired on Christmas Day in 2021, instead of “this joke of a film.”

Podolsky also took issue with the film’s portrayal of Electronic Arts founder Trip Hawkins in its second half. In the film, Hawkins (John Mulaney) pitches a seven-on-seven football video game. But Podolsky noted that the film leaves out Madden’s real response: “I’m a lineman, and I’m not going to be part of any game that’s not eleven against eleven.”

ADVERTISEMENT

According to gaming site Shacknews, an earlier scene wrongly places Hawkins and Madden’s first meeting at a Super Bowl party in 1978. In reality, Den of Geek reports, Hawkins and EA producer Joe Ybarra pitched Madden on an Amtrak train in 1984. That meeting led to John Madden Football, released in 1988 without an official NFL license.

Shacknews also noted that the film adds a subplot in which Al Davis helps secure NFL licensing for the game and holds it over Madden’s head to try to lure him back to coaching the Raiders.

ADVERTISEMENT

In fact, Den of Geek reports that EA didn’t get an official NFL license to include real teams until 1993. Awful Announcing also noted that Madden’s neighbor Vince McGary (comedian Shane Gillis) was invented for the film.

Other critics reached similar conclusions after the release. The Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported on Nov. 19 that the film had a 19% critics score on Rotten Tomatoes. And in a negative review for RogerEbert.com, Robert Daniels wrote that the film “has the woebegone quality of a cheap biography destined to fill Goodwill bins.”

Madden (110 minutes, rated R) is streaming on Amazon Prime Video. For those who want the history Podolsky highlights, Fox’s 90-minute documentary All Madden (2021) and his book Madden & Summerall: How They Revolutionized NFL Broadcasting (2025) are good places to start.

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT