J.J. McCarthy’s big night in the Vikings’ 34-26 win over the Cowboys was overshadowed by a single act of defiance. He threw two touchdown passes and added another on the ground. But the thing that grabbed everyone’s attention was McCarthy’s Griddy-style celebration, which was made popular by teammate Justin Jefferson. But it turns out head coach Kevin O’Connell had already warned the quarterback against it.

“I did it in practice, and I was told not to do it,” J.J. McCarthy told reporters after the game. “So, just me being who I am, it’s like, ‘Oh, now I’m more enticed to do it.’ But if it’s that open, obviously, just get in the end zone no matter what, and be coachable and do what my coach says.

“I’ll definitely get a minus for that one [celebration].”

J.J. McCarthy has already faced heavy criticism in his first season as a starter, which made his celebration even more noticeable. While he insisted that following his coach’s direction matters, his words also suggested there is still growth ahead. No Vikings official has yet confirmed that discipline was coming for the QB. But Kevin O’Connell’s remarks related to McCarthy’s celebration indicated that internal discussions may follow.

What did the coach say?

“We had talked about celebrations and the importance of keeping things respectful,” O’Connell said in the post-game presser. “There are ways to have fun and celebrate with teammates without crossing lines or doing things that might not reflect well on the organization.”

The celebration that clearly irked O’Connell occurred during a second-quarter goal-line bootleg during the Vikings’ Week 15 game. With no defender in front of him, J.J. McCarthy slowed down before crossing the goal line. He held the ball low and performed a modified version of the Griddy. 

The Griddy has become a familiar sight in the NFL, often used as a form of self-expression by wide receivers. But J.J. McCarthy added his own flair to the dance on Sunday night. And it drew mixed reactions from his coaches, fans, and teammates. While some enjoyed the young QB’s confidence, others also questioned it.

Moreover, even though the celebration sparked debate, it was still a key moment in the Vikings’ win over Dallas. It highlighted the tension that comes with developing a young quarterback. 

Why did Kevin O’Connell object to J.J. McCarthy’s celebration? 

While Kevin O’Connell praised J.J. McCarthy’s performance in Week 15, he also later explained why he objected to the QB’s celebration. The coach made it clear that while celebrations are part of today’s NFL, he expects restraint and awareness, especially from his players. Besides, McCarthy’s development also plays a major role in the future success of Minnesota.

“We’re building up to a little bit more experience, a little bit more time on task, a little bit more understanding of what playing the quarterback position at the NFL level is,” O’Connell said in the post-game presser. “I think he [McCarthy] hopefully learned a lesson tonight, if we can be explosive and have some opportunities as the game goes on by just continuing to throw completions.”

So, O’Connell suggested that J.J. McCarthy still has lessons to learn and emphasized focusing on efficiency and execution rather than moments of showmanship.

Regardless, the quarterback had a good day on the field. He ended the game with 15 of 24 passes for 250 yards. He also scored a total of three touchdowns and one interception. It is also important to note that he wasn’t sacked even once, thanks to improved protection around him.

The offensive turnaround in Week 15 was a welcome change from earlier in the season. And McCarthy’s improved play in the back-to-back wins offered some optimism amid a frustrating season for the Vikings. So now, the challenge for O’Connell is to maintain discipline without stifling the confidence of his young QB.

But Vikings fans will hope this version of McCarthy sticks around, even as he continues to learn where celebration ends, and leadership begins. The team will now shift its attention towards Week 16 against the New York Giants.