Five snaps. That’s all it took to ruin Drake Maye’s afternoon in Munich. After a hot start that produced 59 scrimmage yards, one moment early in the game left Maye limping off the field. But it’s not just the injury that has fans angry on social media. It’s the lack of a flag on the play that caused it.
Watch What’s Trending Now!
On third-and-goal from the Detroit 13, the pocket collapsed sooner than Maye expected, and the quarterback paid the price. Lions defensive end Aidan Hutchinson came charging in from the side and took Maye down for a sack.
Maye went to the locker room, and Tommy DeVito took over at quarterback. But fans were focused on what they believed was an illegal tackle. On the replay, it looked like Hutchinson had hit Maye with a hip-drop tackle, and no flag was thrown.
Based on the initial replays, it did look like a hip-drop tackle. Hutchinson wrapped his right arm around Maye’s right shoulder as he brought the quarterback down, landing on Maye’s legs and causing the injury. That seems in line with the league’s definition of the tackle.
“A hip-drop tackle occurs when a defender wraps up a ball carrier and rotates or swivels his hips, unweighting himself and dropping onto ball carrier’s legs during the tackle.”
The league banned the tackle in 2024 because of how often it injures players. Dropping onto a player’s legs, as happened here, causes lower-body injuries at a rate 20 times higher than other tackles. Ravens tight end Mark Andrews suffered a fractured left fibula and ankle ligament damage in 2023 after Logan Wilson brought him down with one, and Buccaneers receiver Chris Godwin’s 2024 season ended with a dislocated ankle that required surgery.
Even FOX analyst Greg Olsen agreed it looked like one. So why wasn’t there a penalty? Front Office Sports’ Mark Maske explained on X: “There are some suggestions that Aidan Hutchinson’s sack of Drake Maye was an illegal hip drop tackle. Remember that all elements of a hip-drop tackle (grab, swivel, unweight, fall on leg or legs) must be there for it to be illegal, under NFL rules.”
FOX rules analyst Mike Pereira backed that up. “Three things have to happen: you have to unweight yourself, swivel all around the back and land on the back of his leg below the knee. This was more of a horse collar-type pulled down from behind. [But] certainly not a horse collar penalty.”
Not long after, the NFL’s Walt Anderson confirmed that analysis through a league spokesperson. The league had also sent teams a video highlighting this part of the rule earlier in the season.
But none of it stopped fans from lashing out once the clip was posted on social media.
One fan had asked Pereira to explain the tackle, writing, “@NFL @NFLonFOX @MikePereira please define a hip drop tackle. Then please tell us how tf it’s a rule if this is not gonna be called.” Soon after Pereira’s explanation, another fan hit back:
“B——-, if Mike can’t see that’s a hip drop tackle he needs to hang it up. Watch the video – Hutchinson jumps, takes his weight and swings his legs into the back of Drake’s Mayes legs. Literally what the rule is designed to prevent. Refs protecting refs.”
Enforcement of the hip-drop rule has been in the spotlight all season. In Week 4, Cleveland Browns defensive tackle Adin Huntington made a controversial tackle on Aaron Rodgers. He wasn’t flagged on the field but later appeared on the league’s weekly accountability list. In another instance, what looked like a hip-drop tackle by Daiyan Henley on Travis Kelce also went unpunished.
The missed calls haven’t gone unnoticed, as one fan pointed out. “Been saying it for weeks them implementing the ‘flag’ for hip drops was a gimmick.”
Another fan even suggested the odds were stacked against Maye from the start. “Nobody protects Drake Maye smh, most hated QB in the league.” Maye has faced plenty of criticism since last season, when the Patriots went 14-3 but fell short of winning the Super Bowl.
Interestingly, while Hutchinson faced no consequences on the field, one fan believed he paid for it in a different way. “Then Hutch immediately injured himself celebrating, in a karmic ‘Ball don’t lie’ kind of way.” The fan was referring to the injury Hutchinson suffered while jumping to celebrate the sack. He went off the field and later left the stadium on crutches.
With Maye out, DeVito stepped in, and the Patriots went on to lose 35-10. Afterward, Mike Vrabel gave an update on his quarterback.
“He wasn’t able to finish. We’ll see what the severity of that is once we get back and kind of go from there.”

