The Kansas City Chiefs are walking a tightrope with their kicking game. Harrison Butker remains a three-time Super Bowl champion with a massive legacy in town, but his operation has hit a turbulent patch this season. With accuracy dipping on long-range attempts and inconsistency showing up week after week, the front office has quietly started exploring contingency plans behind the scenes.
Watch What’s Trending Now!
That underlying tension boiled over when NFL Network’s Mike Garafolo reported on X that Kansas City has brought in 42-year-old veteran kicker Matt Prater for a workout. Prater spent the 2025 campaign going 18-of-20 on field goals for the Buffalo Bills, hit the open market as a free agent, and remains ready to extend a career that started back in 2006.
The timing of the Prater evaluation intensified questions about the team’s direction at the position, especially since the Chiefs already brought in former Baltimore Ravens kicker Justin Tucker. He signed in late October after a year away from football, giving Kansas City an established alternative on their practice squad while Butker battles through his toughest statistical stretch so far.
Through the first ten weeks (nine games) of the campaign, Harrison Butker has converted 12 of his 19 field goal attempts, logging a career-low 63.2% scoring percentage in the process. He’s missed 7 field goal attempts so far – the most in his career so far, and there are still eight weeks of regular season football left.
This dip in accuracy includes six missed on eight attempts from 50+ yards, highlighting the loss of distance control on deep tries. For a player who once booted a 69-yard field goal during the preseason against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, the contrast between his historical ceiling and current output has been jarring, to say the least.
Now, despite the mounting misses and media narratives, special teams coordinator Dave Toub chose to publicly double down on his veteran starter, pointing to his long track record of playoff execution rather than pushing the panic button during a tight conference race.
“We’re gonna keep pounding it. We’re gonna keep working it,” Toub said last Thursday. “He’s going to come through it. We’re confident that he will.”
Head coach Andy Reid had also echoed that sentiment when addressing reporters ahead of their Week 10 clash with the Atlanta Falcons, announcing that he’s sticking with Butker.
“Harrison has done such a great job for us over time,” Coach Reid said. “Sometimes you go through these little peaks and valleys. I’m going to give him a chance to work through them, and we’ll see how things go.”
But that patience and grace last only until Butker costs them a game, and the fact that the Chiefs are indeed looking at other kickers goes to show that the front office’s stance and intentions might not match the public statements they’re putting out. But it’s not all bad. Former Chiefs defensive tackle Bill Maas, for one, believes the team’s recent moves are all about lighting a fire under Butker.
“I think that bringing him in and putting him on the practice squad was a move to try to motivate, refocus [Butker],” Maas said on the Chiefs Zone after the Chiefs signed Tucker. “He didn’t have anybody pushing him on the roster. There was no other kicker on the team. And now you bring somebody in, and the red light goes off. And you start refocusing on what you’re doing. I think that it was a motivational move. I’d be really surprised if they part ways with [Butker].”
As for Prater, if he ends up a Chief, he brings a proven career pedigree featuring an 83.8% field goal percentage across 19 seasons in the NFL. Known historically for his booming leg and having previously held the NFL record for the longest successful field goal (64 yards), Prater has proven that he can handle the pressure of kicking outdoors as well as in cold weather.
That veteran stability is precisely what makes his presence on the workout block such an ominous sign for Harrison Butker’s job security in Kansas City. When a championship front office brings in an established specialist with 425 field goals made while their incumbent starter is stuck with a deep-ball slump, the margin for error doesn’t exist anymore.
All eyes now turn to Arrowhead Stadium as the Chiefs prepare for their Week 11 clash with the Arizona Cardinals. Whether Butker can lock in his mechanics under pressure or if management decides the kicking operation needs a seismic veteran will be the story to watch out for as Kansas City chases another Lombardi Trophy.

