feature-image

Imago

feature-image

Imago

The Rocky Top has touched rock bottom. Once the program everyone aspired to beat, much like UConn today, is coming off a program-worst 16-14 overall record while going 8-8 in the SEC. Understandably, the once-dream destination for almost all top recruits in the country now has no players left for the 2026-27 roster. Safe to say, under Kim Caldwell’s leadership, the team has experienced a decline, but of course, she’s not the only one to blame as per everything that has recently unfolded. 

Watch What’s Trending Now!

 Jaida Civil, who was the last player left, entered the transfer portal, leaving Caldwell’s side reeling. Oliviyah Edwards, the No. 2 recruit in the SC Next 100 class of 2026, has requested a release from her national letter of intent with the Lady Volunteers. With the program seemingly falling apart, ESPN broadcaster Holly Rowe, however, has slammed the Volunteer AD, Danny White.

ADVERTISEMENT

“What Danny White is allowing to happen to @LadyVol_Hoops is making me so sad. Gut-wrenching to watch him let one of the greatest programs in women’s sports history disintegrate. I am devastated,” Rowe posted. However, the post has now been deleted.

When a historic program reaches a point where the entire returning roster exits the transfer portal and a top recruit requests release from her signing, the focus often shifts upward from coaching performance to institutional oversight, as has been the case here.

ADVERTISEMENT

White was hired back in 2021, and the Tennessee Lady Vols have accomplished very little during his time. They haven’t been seeded higher than No. 3 and have peaked at the Sweet 16. They haven’t been ranked higher than No. 15 in the final AP Poll. But why target the AD rather than coach Kim Caldwell? Maybe because he refused to fire her. Fans have been calling for her dismissal, and reports suggest that people close to him were urging him to move on.

ADVERTISEMENT

The suggestion was put forth largely because of the record, but also because of the way she handled the players. She criticized her squad and accused them of “quitting on her” and benched Kaiya Wynn on senior day, which caused her to leave and lose the dressing room, per many analysts. 

The situation became even more sensitive because the Lady Vols are not a typical rebuilding program. Tennessee’s eight national championships and 18 Final Four appearances under legendary coach Pat Summitt established expectations that extend beyond ordinary transition cycles. That historical weight helps explain why Rowe framed the moment as a threat to the identity of “one of the greatest programs in women’s sports history,” rather than simply a difficult season under a new head coach.

ADVERTISEMENT

Yet, Danny White has backed the coach he hired.

“I think she is doing a great job,” White said on WMNL. “I am as confident in her as I was the day I hired her – more confident. Just getting a chance to work closely with her and see how talented she is as a basketball mind, as a leader.” 

ADVERTISEMENT

White has continued to stand by Caldwell even as roster departures accelerated this offseason, reinforcing the perception among some analysts that the administration is prioritizing continuity while the program resets. That context likely contributed to why Rowe’s criticism centered on leadership decisions rather than targeting Caldwell directly.

To be fair to Danny White, there are reports that Gabe Lazo, the former assistant coach, undermined coach Caldwell, which led to the season unraveling. However, that was completely denied by many former players who spoke up. Nevertheless, there is a world where White is redeemed, and coach Caldwell succeeds. 

ADVERTISEMENT

There were also additional flashpoints during the season that shaped public reaction to the program’s direction. Caldwell dismissed leading scorer Ruby Whitehorn shortly before the start of the season, publicly questioned her team’s effort at times, and later saw senior Kaiya Wynn step away from the program late in the year. Those developments unfolded alongside Tennessee’s 16-14 finish and added to concerns about retention and locker-room stability.

For now, Kim Caldwell remains the Tennessee coach, and all hope is not lost, as there is something that she can still do to improve matters.

Kim Caldwell should make one key change to turn things around

Despite losing everyone to the portal, this scenario is not uncommon, as 1,000+ players are already changing teams. In addition, Caldwell had a successful first year, finishing 24-10  and reaching the Sweet 16. Going forward, she can return to prioritizing fit over the on-paper metrics. 

ADVERTISEMENT

Roster turnover of this scale is still unusual for a program of Tennessee’s stature, but it comes during an era in which the transfer portal has reshaped roster construction across women’s college basketball. That reality is part of why some observers believe the reset could allow Caldwell to rebuild the roster around players suited specifically to her system rather than inherited pieces.

article-image

Imago

“I think the system and this situation become fixable for Coach Kim Caldwell, and in the midst of this chaos, I think she can actually win here because it’s going to come down to recruiting players who fit her system, not just chasing star rankings and ratings,” Tennessee insider Paige Dauer said. 

ADVERTISEMENT

The 37-year-old plays a unique, press-heavy, frequent-rotation-style basketball, which includes high-volume threes. She needs the players to buy in, or the entire system falls apart, something that happened this past season. Now, she starts with a clean slate and can bring in the players she needs, rather than just the conventionally best talent.

“There’s a self-scouting element here because for coach Kim Caldwell, if she believes like the system is the identity, the players have to match it,” Dauer said. 

So far, Tennessee has only had departures in this portal, but it has only just started. Kim Caldwell has let go of two of her assistant coaches and hired one replacement in Bill Ferrera. Caldwell is under pressure to deliver, but she has the blueprint from her first season to do so. Only time will tell whether she can turn things around at Tennessee or if someone else will be needed to step in.

Share this with a friend:

Link Copied!

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Written by

author-image

Soham Kulkarni

1,417 Articles

Soham Kulkarni is a WNBA Writer at EssentiallySports, where he focuses on data-backed reporting and performance analysis. A Sports Management graduate, he examines how spacing in efficiency zones, shot selection, and statistical shifts drive results. His work goes beyond the numbers on the scoreboard, helping readers see how underlying trends affect player efficiency and the evolving strategies of the women’s game. With a detail-oriented and analytical approach, Soham turns complex data into accessible narratives that bring clarity to the fastest-moving moments of basketball. His reporting captures not just what happened, but why it matters, showing fans how small efficiency gains, defensive structures, and tempo shifts can alter outcomes. At ES, he provides a sharper, stats-first lens on the WNBA’s present and future.

Know more

Edited by

editor-image

Deepali Verma

ADVERTISEMENT