Ty Jerome was ending an incredible regular season, the best of his career if we may, as he entered the playoffs with the Cleveland Cavaliers. His name in the Sixth Man of the Year finalists is a nod to his run. But come knockoff rounds, it can be expected that the momentum would die down. But for Jerome? The case was a little different. Making it to the Game 1 against the Miami Heat in round 1 of the 2025 NBA playoffs, Ty brought out a monster. 28 points to almost eclipse the hard work of the team’s superstar and his childhood friend Donovan Mitchell. 16 points in just the fourth quarter of what he defined as, “Solid, solid Game 1.” And all the while, taunting the Heat players and their fans with the “too short” hand gesture. Jerome had elevated his output. But as it may, he hit rock bottom just as quickly.

Entering the round 2 of the playoffs against the Indiana Pacers, Jerome hasn’t been like the one we had come to know. Whether he had lost his mojo or was in a temporary slump, the key to HC Kenny Atkinson’s second unit is failing repeatedly to bounce back. The expectations for Jerome were clear: provide punch, pace, and poise off the bench. Instead, what followed in the second round has been an unraveling. Through three games against the Indiana Pacers, Jerome has shot just 10-for-42 from the field. Game 3 was arguably his lowest point, finishing 1-for-8 with minimal impact on either end.

The Cavaliers may have walked out of Indianapolis with a convincing 126-104 win, but it’s clear that their second unit is still searching for answers—and Jerome is at the center of that conundrum. After the strong 64-18 regular season, Cleveland is at risk of crashing out of the playoffs early without making the Boston Celtics sweat in the Eastern Conference Finals. However, it’s still too soon to count Cleveland out. And as it appears, they have not lost hope on their 27-year-old guard either.

Post-game, a reporter asked head coach Kenny Atkinson, “We’ve seen some smaller minutes from Ty. What do you see from him?” Understandably, Atkinson didn’t shy away from the topic. “Man he’s struggling. But this is the playoffs. You go through stretches. I just—I love Ty. I know what he can bring. We need him in this series, especially with DG [Darius Garland] hobbled. So, we’re just going to kep encouraging him to be aggressive. He’ll get it back, ’cause he’s got extreme mental toughness. He’s gonna go down swinging if he’s going down. So, that’s there. We’re gonna keep rolling with him.”

Atkinson’s comments weren’t just about defending a player. They were about reaffirming belief in someone the coaching staff and locker room have leaned on all season. But as was expected, his minutes going down came into notice quite easily. In Game 3 Ty was only given 13 minutes on the hardwood. The last time that he had played for that long or close to it was in February against Oklahoma for 12 minutes. And that’s the impact the 24th overall pick from 2019 has had on the roster. And Donovan Mitchell echoed the HC’s sentiment in his own words:

Mitchell was asked, “Ty’s had a couple of rough games. What can you do as the leader, as the teammate to get him out or does he just have to play?” With no breath lost, the star guard responded, “I’m not worried about Ty Jerome, man. He’s shown us all year who he is—showed us in the first round. He’s just not making shots right now, and that’s fine. Understand that—it’s coming. He works hard, he’s in the gym. It’s not like he’s not putting in the work. I’ve seen this my whole life with him. There’s no need to overdo it, like patting him on the back constantly. Just say, ‘Hey, you’re good. This is what you do. It’s coming.’ We all believe in him.”

And yet, the timing of Jerome’s slump couldn’t be more precarious.

At the end of the season, the Cavaliers will face a pivotal contract decision. Jerome is eligible for a deal worth up to $14.3 million next season via Early Bird rights—a cap-exceeding offer, but one that demands conviction. Unlike players under full Bird rights, Cleveland can’t match any offer that surpasses their limit. The Pistons, projected to have cap space and in need of ball-handling support, loom as potential bidders. There’s also the Bickerstaff connection: Jerome originally signed with Cleveland under now-Detroit head coach J.B. Bickerstaff.

That puts pressure not just on Jerome, but on the Cavs’ front office to evaluate, in real time, whether the past season outweighs the present struggles. Does the Game 1 Miami hero version of Jerome represent the norm? Or has the playoff spotlight illuminated a ceiling Cleveland can’t ignore?

Internally, the tone remains supportive. There’s an element of truth there that goes beyond loyalty. Jerome’s game is built on rhythm, and the Cavs’ first-round injuries forced him into overdrive. Now, with Garland back, albeit hobbled, and Mobley anchoring the paint, the rotations are recalibrating. Jerome isn’t being asked to carry anymore, just to contribute. But the window for impact is shrinking, and patience in the playoffs is rarely unconditional. Still, there’s no panic—not from Mitchell, not from Atkinson.

But what happens in the next few games could be career-defining because playoff slumps are common. But $14.3 million decisions? Those come with stakes that don’t just define a series. They define futures.

What Ty Jerome Brings When He’s Right

To understand the dilemma, you have to first understand the value. Ty Jerome isn’t in the rotation just because of vibes or veteran handshakes. When he’s right, Jerome is a connective tissue player. He plays the game like a jazz rhythm section—steady, intuitive, always sensing the next pass before it opens.

His feel for pace control—especially in hybrid lineups where Garland and Mitchell are staggered—makes Cleveland’s second units more organized. His secondary playmaking allows Mitchell to operate off-ball. He doesn’t hijack the offense, but he doesn’t vanish either.

What’s more, Jerome has a high-level understanding of zone offense, a structure the Cavs leaned on in Game 3. He knows where the soft spots are and how to create angles without always needing a screen. In the locker room, he’s been described by coaches and players as a “thermometer” — steady regardless of the scoreline, respected regardless of role. That matters in a playoff cauldron.

But right now, his greatest traits aren’t translating to production. His shot isn’t falling. His reads are a tick slow. And the margin in this series is too thin for sentiment. Mitchell’s faith. Atkinson’s loyalty. The locker room’s belief. All valid. All real. But basketball is a results game.

So what are the Cavs’ alternatives? Could Sam Merrill—an elite shooter—offer better spacing to stretch Indiana’s defense? The Pacers have shown they’re willing to sag off non-shooters. Merrill forces them to stay honest. That alone could free Mitchell from constant traps.

Could Craig Porter Jr. give them more lateral quickness and backcourt defense? If Jerome isn’t hitting shots and is struggling on-ball defensively, the case for Porter’s athleticism grows stronger. He might not orchestrate like Jerome, but he might make up for it with energy and disruption.

Could Garland and Mitchell’s minutes be staggered more, reducing the need for Jerome to carry possessions solo? With Garland still regaining rhythm, it may not be a full solution—but even partial staggering can tilt the floor and buy time for Jerome to ease back in.

None of these tweaks requires benching Jerome completely. But they acknowledge what the film is showing: the current mix isn’t working, and Cleveland can’t afford static lineups in a live playoff fire.

What this really comes down to isn’t just Ty Jerome. It’s the larger question of depth versus dependability.

Cleveland’s bench has been functional, not dominant. Strus has delivered. Okoro brings intensity, but lacks gravity. Hunter is still finding his rhythm. Porter remains a burst of energy, not a possession-to-possession organizer. Merrill is a marksman, but one still unproven in the fire of extended playoff minutes.

That leaves Mitchell carrying a disproportionate load. He’s proving capable. But for how long? How deep into a postseason can one star carry when relief is unreliable?

For Jerome, this is the tension point. He’s proven to be one of Cleveland’s smartest and most adaptable guards. His profile is not built on streaky scoring—it’s built on stability. That’s what Atkinson is betting on. That’s what Mitchell is defending. But with every playoff minute, that bet meets pressure. And how Jerome responds—not just with shot-making, but with rhythm, reads, and confidence—will shape not just Cleveland’s series, but their structure going forward.

Because in May, everything is magnified. Every possession matters. And for Ty Jerome, the next few games are more than a moment. They might be a referendum.