The Boston Red Sox are facing a pivotal offseason choice: overpay to keep a star free agent, or execute a bold trade that could reshape their infield for years to come.

The Red Sox could save money, get Ketel Marte, and solve their infield problems. However, it all comes down to their Gold Glove star, Wilyer Abreu.

“He’s going to have very good trade value,” said Robbie Hyde on his YouTube Channel. “To keep bringing up the Red Sox, but I see a fit here as well… if Alex Bregman doesn’t come back. You can put Marcelo Mayer at third base, and Ketel Marte can play second base.”

Alex Bregman opted out after an All-Star season with Boston in 2025. His decision came without a qualifying offer attached after last winter in Boston. The Red Sox still hold interest, although long-term demands could complicate talks. Reports suggest Detroit could bid after pursuing him during the previous winter as well.

Amid all this, the Red Sox have a trade piece in Wilyer Abreu that they could use to strengthen their team.

Wilyer Abreu has been a recent topic of trade talks. If the Red Sox don’t get Bregman, they could trade  Abreu for Ketel Marte.

Marte posted 28 homers with an .893 OPS and 145 wRC+ last year. Reports linked him to trade talks as Arizona seeks pitching depth soon again. A deal using Abreu and pitching could move Marcelo Mayer to third base, and the $116.5 million Ketel Marte fits at second base.

Meanwhile, the Boston Red Sox are juggling an outfield that’s starting to feel like a reality show: too many personalities, not enough space.

The Red Sox can’t delay choosing between Wilyer Abreu and Jarren Duran

Somewhere between flashy speed and dependable power, Wilyer Abreu and Jarren Duran are waiting for their cue, but the spotlight can only hit one.

Duran offers elite speed, stealing 30 bases in 2025 and creating constant pressure. His defense remains inconsistent, with a costly error against the Yankees highlighting potential risks.

However, trading Duran could yield a high upside, as it would address Boston’s rotation needs, improve the starting pitching, and enhance the roster balance.

On the other hand, Wilyer Abreu provides reliable power, hitting 28 home runs over 480 at-bats in 2025 with consistent contact. His left-handed bat projects well into a middle-order role for multiple seasons. Moving Abreu would weaken the lineup’s stability, but his value could attract premium pitching in return.

Considering both options, Boston appears well-positioned to retain Abreu while effectively leveraging Duran’s current trade value.

Trading Duran smartly could solve pitching gaps, leaving fans both relieved and slightly heartbroken. And Abreu’s steady power ensures Boston keeps one reliable bat while avoiding an outfield crisis next season.