The Brewers surprised many in 2025 with a deep postseason run before falling to a stronger Dodgers team. That run showed that winning in MLB does not require a massive payroll or a roster full of superstars. Success comes from having the right mix of talented players aligned with the team’s goals. The real challenge is sustaining that success over time.
Watch What’s Trending Now!
It only lasts when players feel a sense of stability and trust in the organization, and that’s an area where the Brewers have not always built the strongest reputation.
From trading CC Sabathia back in 2009 to moving Corbin Burnes in 2024, the pattern has been clear.
Business decisions tend to take priority over chasing championships. And now, with Freddy Peralta’s name starting to come up in trade talk, it feels like the team could be heading down the same path again.
Thus, leaving fans and analysts wondering whether President Matt Arnold sold them a vision he never truly planned to commit to.
“We have a 29-year-old pitcher in the absolute prime of his physical shape who threw almost 177 innings last season and proved to be the ace we always hoped for. But because he is entering the final year of his contract before free agency, Matt Arnold’s office sees a walking dollar sign instead of a trophy. It’s the classic Milwaukee dilemma,”
Brewers Fan Central host shared via YouTube.
Imago
Credits: IMAGO
So, if you’re a Brewers fan, the one guy you’ve probably had your eye on all offseason is Freddy Peralta. And why not?
Because he’s the ace of this staff, no question about it. The 29-year-old was lights-out in 2025, posting a 2.70 ERA over 33 starts and nearly 177 innings. He finished fifth in the NL Cy Young voting. Still, ever since the season ended, his name has been everywhere in trade rumors!
Honestly, there’s a strong case that Milwaukee shouldn’t move him. Sure, they could get a hefty return, but if the Brewers truly want a shot at knocking off the Dodgers, having Peralta at the front of the rotation gives them a much better chance than shipping him out. A rotation built around Peralta, Brandon Woodruff, Quinn Priester, Jacob Misiorowski, plus one of Chad Patrick, Logan Henderson, or Tobias Myers, can go toe-to-toe with just about anyone.
There’s also a bigger picture here.
The young players coming up through the system need to believe that if they perform, they’ll actually get the chance to stick around and compete. Rather than assuming their time in Milwaukee ends once they’ve gone through arbitration a few times, or even sooner.
The question now is whether the Brewers’ front office is really hearing that message. Or if they’re preparing to follow the same old script again.
The Yankees might be the gainer from a Brewers trade
As soon as the Brewers started floating Peralta as a possible trade piece, it didn’t take long for the Yankees to jump to the front of the line. And why not? With Gerrit Cole and Carlos Rodón expected to miss the start of the season, New York is clearly looking for rotation help.
From Milwaukee’s perspective, the return would need to include players who can contribute right away and still have value down the road. Someone like Jose Caballero would give the Brewers another option if Joey Ortiz’s offensive struggles continue. On top of that, Caballero showed real growth at the plate with the Yankees, so maybe all he needed was a fresh start.
Then there’s Will Warren, who would give Milwaukee a young, controllable arm with upside, even if he’s had some bumps along the way.
And honestly, if you’ve followed the Brewers long enough, this kind of thinking feels very familiar. It’s the same blueprint they’ve leaned on for years. Flip a proven star for speed, control, and potential, and trust the system to make it work again.
