Imago
credits: MLB.COM
Imago
credits: MLB.COM
“You can allow yourself to get pretty excited when you’re adding a guy of that caliber,” said Blue Jays manager John Schneider, looking ahead to his new starting pitcher’s long-awaited return. After more than a year away from Major League action due to Tommy John surgery, former Cy Young winner Shane Bieber is ready to take the mound once again.
Watch What’s Trending Now!
Bieber last played on April 2, 2024, pitching for the Cleveland Guardians. He threw 12 scoreless innings over his first two starts of that season before undergoing Tommy John surgery
He joined Toronto on July 31, 2025, in a trade with Cleveland, signing a $26 million one-year deal with a $16 million team option for 2026. Following a successful minor-league rehab assignment—seven starts with a sparkling 1.86 ERA and 37 strikeouts over 29 innings—he has shown he’s prepared for major-league competition.
Top Stories
According to FOX Sports, Bieber’s much-anticipated Blue Jays debut is scheduled for Friday against the Miami Marlins: “John Schneider told reporters that Shane Bieber will make his debut on Friday in Miami. Bieber has not pitched since April 2, 2024 after having Tommy John surgery while with the Guardians.”
John Schneider told reporters that Shane Bieber will make his debut on Friday in Miami.
Bieber has not pitched since April 2, 2024 after having Tommy John surgery while with the Guardians. pic.twitter.com/cVUGg7E8pS
— FOX Sports: MLB (@MLBONFOX) August 18, 2025
Recent Triple-A outings have shown encouraging signs for Bieber’s velocity: his four-seam fastball averaged 92.5 mph (up 1.2 mph from 2022), with similar upticks across his slider, cutter, knuckle-curve, and changeup—each pitch now closer to peak early-career numbers. Schneider expressed confidence in Bieber’s health and mechanics, stating, “There are zero red flags.” He also lauded Bieber’s ability to dominate hitters with a variety of pitches: “You can put him in the category of some pretty good pitchers where they can dominate areas with different pitches.”
With Toronto atop their division at 73-53 and enjoying one of their strongest seasons in recent memory, Bieber’s arrival adds another layer of strength—but also tough choices—to the Blue Jays’ starting rotation.
Six Arms, Five Spots: Toronto’s Rotation Conundrum
The Blue Jays now have six legitimate starting pitchers but only five rotation slots—a good problem, yet one with real implications. According to Sportsnet’s Ben Nicholson-Smith, Toronto is considering multiple strategies.
On weeks with off days, the Jays could rotate all six starters, providing extra rest especially for veterans like Gausman, Scherzer, and Bieber. This approach minimizes arm strain and could pay dividends late in the season.
If needed, one starter could shift into a long-relief role. Eric Lauer, who has performed well, is a prime candidate should the Jays opt for this arrangement.
Sticking with the traditional approach, then resting starters as needed, would keep the bullpen intact and maintain the rhythm for the team’s frontline arms.
Schneider left the decision open-ended: “We have to see where we are in that when that time arrives. So it’ll depend on what our starters have done, what our bullpen’s like. We have multiple plans in place, to see where everyone is (as far as) workload, health (and) stuff like that. They’re all aware of it.”
As Bieber steps onto the mound for his first start since April 2024, Toronto will be watching closely. Should they seize the moment with a six-man rotation or stick to the classic five? With pitching talent plentiful, the Jays face a welcome—if challenging—choice.
Written by
Edited by
Abhishek Rajan