The Blue Jays’ struggles extend far beyond their disappointing 10-15 record. A seemingly endless parade to the injured list has now claimed another key slugger after the team’s 8-6 loss to the Guardians on Friday.
Watch What’s Trending Now!
“Nathan Lukes left the game in Toronto after being in agony running to second base on this double,” Talkin’ Baseball tweeted on Saturday.
In the first inning, Nathan Lukes hit a leadoff double off the Guardians’ Gavin Williams. After hitting a leadoff double, he was visibly in discomfort and appeared to tweak something in his lower body while sliding into second base. Manager John Schneider and a team trainer visited before removing him from the game.
Nathan Lukes left the game in Toronto after being in agony running to second base on this double
Doctors diagnosed him with a left hamstring strain, which means he’ll reportedly be on the IL for a minimum of ten days. The Jays placed Myles Straw in right field in the second game. And with that, the Jays lost a slugger who’s hitting .250 and even took the leadoff hit on Friday. Even in the last game against the Angels, Lukes recorded one run, one RBI, and 2 hits. And after Friday’s double, the 31-year-old had 11 hits in his last 21 at-bats.
So, while the Jays are in no position to afford injuries anymore, a red-hot batter like Lukes getting sidelined means a lot. Lukes joins an already crowded IL that includes key rotation arms like Jose Berrios and recent acquisition Shane Bieber, not to mention offensive cornerstones like Kirk and Springer, draining the team of talent on all fronts. Things are surely getting far more challenging for Schneider.
Eric Lauer, the stopgap solution for the Jays’ battered rotation, also had tape on his neck against the Angels. And considering how Max Scherzer gave up 7 ERs without a single strikeout on Friday, there are enough reasons for the fans to panic with the team’s expanding IL.
The Blue Jays fans are in a panic
Fans are wondering whether there is a curse on the Blue Jays, as so many top performers are getting sidelined with injuries. “We are beyond cursed,” one fan said. The Red Sox faced the “curse of Bambino” that deprived them of a World Series ring for 86 years. But what have the Blue Jays done to get cursed? Is it because they let Bo Bichette go? Well, cursed or not, the impact is real, with the Jays ranking second-last in the AL East.
“We can’t have nice things,” another added. Take Yesavage, for example. He had a historic 2025 postseason for the Blue Jays. He finished with a 3-1 record, a 3.58 ERA, and 39 SOs over 27.2 innings. Fans had high hopes for him for the new season. But Yesavage began the season on the IL with a right shoulder impingement. He hasn’t played yet.
So, the Jays fans might panic even if someone plays better. “Too many injuries for Toronto this season, but once they’re healthy, watch out,” one user remarked. Last year, the Jays recorded the most runs scored in a single postseason with 105 total runs, averaging 5.8 runs per game.
However, this year, the Jays haven’t had their full strength for a single game. And as the IL continues to grow, it’s uncertain when the team will ever be at full strength.
“Blue Jays gotta sign Johnny Giunta at this point,” one fan remarked. While signing former college baseball player Giunta might be extreme, the Jays called up their prospect, Yohendrick Pinango, from Triple-A Buffalo. He will serve as a backup to Straw, who will replace Lukes. “Oof, Lukes looked rough,” another added.
Lukes’ slide looked rough; his recovery period could extend, meaning the team would need to manage Straw’s workload. Hence, chances are Pinango could make his MLB debut soon.
