Since Mike Trout signed that $426.5 million contract for 12 years in 2019, his performance has been minutely scrutinized. Trout couldn’t justify his price tag with stats. But that seems to be changing in 2026.

Trout already belted 10 homers at .258 this year and is currently second in MLB with a .433 OBP. After years of injury-laden seasons, the Los Angeles Angels are finally getting a return on their investment. Still, for insiders, this might be the best time for the Angels to look for trading partners for Trout.

“The Angels need to look into trading him right now, as his value will never be higher, and his contract is still a major risk for them,” the Athletic’s Keith Law said.

Trout’s contract features a full no-trade clause with no opt-out. This ensures he remains with the franchise through his age-39 season, with a high average annual value of $35.5 million. That $35.5 million AAV till his age 39 will always be a liability for the team.

Get the EssentiallySports Daily Newsletter. Stay ahead of the game with daily updates, exclusive stories, expert takes, and the biggest moments from the world's most popular sports.

Trout is now 34, and even if he produces MVP-level stats, it’s very unlikely that he will continue to do so until his age 39.

Hence, per Keith Law, the best time for the Angels to look to trade Trout is now.

Trout last played a full season back in 2020.

Since 2021, he has yet to play a full 162-game season. In 2021, a severe right calf strain restricted him to just 36 games. Next year, a rare back condition limited him to 119 games. Then in 2023, a fractured hamate bone in his left hand kept him out for most of the second half, with a short-lived return in August.

In 2024, he tore the meniscus in his left knee in April. And last year, Trout re-injured his surgically repaired left knee, ending up with just 29 games into the season,

This year, Trout started healthy and sound. Rather, he is seemingly back to his old self, having already hit 10 home runs and slashed .258/.433/.550 with 21 RBI and a .983 OPS.

“Mike Trout is having his best season since 2022, as he’s fully healthy and producing like a star at the plate again, with power and patience and high batting averages,” Law noted.

But considering his injury history and age, the Angels might not get any more chances to offer him to the suitors. However, why trade him when the Angels are finally getting their return?

The Angels need some real prospects.

But with their $172 million payroll in 2026, Trout’s contract is eating away at a cool $37 million. Saving those bucks could bring a few names to the clubhouse. However, will any team pursue an age-34 slugger with a $37 million AAV, even if the Angels absorb a little?

Mike Trout’s probable landing spots

The first destination Trout might fit in is the Cincinnati Reds.

Yes, they are a small-market team, and the Angels need to absorb a significant amount to let him go; still, the trade could work. For the Reds, they do not have a diverse power-hitting staff apart from Ely De La Cruz. So, adding someone like Trout, who would also bring veteran experience, could be a deal here.

The Angels absorbing $20 million AAV and the Reds taking up the remaining $17 million could work.

The Reds have a long list of prospects who could make the deal sweeter for the Angels. For instance, someone like Tyson Lewis, who scored 9 homers at .311 last year, could be an option.

The next team could be the Los Angeles Dodgers. That would be a dream reunion of Shohei Ohtani and Mike Trout.

While the Dodgers already have names like Freddie Freeman, Mookie Betts, and Ohtani and may not need more power in the lineup, LA is always hungry to get marquee names.

Getting someone like Trout at a lower price point and keeping him as backup sounds like a perfect Dodgers-like strategy.