Justin Thomas came from seven shots back to win at Southern Hills in 2022, so pressure on a golf course isn’t new to him. What threw him was something much smaller: his 20-month-old daughter, swinging a putter in their backyard, doing something he still can’t wrap his head around.

Thomas has thought about this for a while now, he just needed the right moment to put it into words: golf is the one sport where a toddler can genuinely outdo a pro on a single shot.

“The fact that like our 20-month-old daughter who has no idea what any of this is could actually make that putt and I could miss it. That cannot happen in another sport,” Thomas said in a We need a Fourth podcast.

83% of our readers couldn't break par yesterday

Changing winds, tricky bunkers, and quirky breaks test every shot. Beat par, compare scores, and return tomorrow for a new challenge.

TEE OFF HERE↗

The anecdote traces back to a family putting green Thomas and his wife, Jillian, keep in their yard. Their daughter, who turns two in a few months, has taken to swinging a putter without any real technique, according to Thomas. During one attempt, she sank a shot from roughly 15 feet, a distance Thomas estimated even the best players in the world convert only 25 to 30 percent of the time.

Get the Essentially Golf Newsletter. The pulse of today's golf world — daily news from fairways across the globe and tips to improve your game.

A Point He’d Already Been Making

Thomas had actually been building toward this idea earlier in the same conversation, before his daughter came up. He pushed back on a comparison between a rough amateur round and a pro blowing a routine play in another sport, arguing the two aren’t close. Missing a short pass as a quarterback isn’t like carding a 78 on a tough course, since a bad round in golf can still land within shouting distance of what a pro shoots. It’s the same logic he circled back to with the putting green story, just applied to a different gap.

That gap between a toddler’s accidental success and a tour pro’s structured failure is what Thomas pointed to as proof of golf’s unpredictability. He drew a direct comparison to other sports to make the point land: a basketball fan off the street cannot walk onto a court and outshoot LeBron James from three-point range. In golf, on any given hole, that kind of upset is possible. It’s not the same in basketball, tennis, or soccer, where reps and mechanics keep the gap between pros and everyone else pretty consistent.

Thomas tied the story back to his own grind, mentioning the 44 he’d shot the day before and how much work goes into shaving strokes off a handicap. In fact, the story originated that same night. He was lying in bed with his wife, Jillian, still turning the putt over in his head, and brought it to the podcast still fresh from that conversation. A putt like that, sunk by a kid who’s never held a club with intent, cuts against everything a pro spends years building. That contrast is what stuck with him.

A major title takes preparation, patience, and a lot of missed cuts along the way. A 15-foot putt from a toddler takes none of that, and she still made it.

Thomas wasn’t trying to make a point about his daughter being gifted. He was making a point about golf itself, a game where skill and chance sit closer together than in almost anything else. That’s the part he can’t get past. Even with two major championships and years of experience on the PGA Tour behind him, that reality is hard to reconcile, no matter how much preparation goes into every round he plays.